Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Flows and Textures TLC's avatar

I see the use for this model in response to writing assignments for 9-12 US English. Once I’ve defined the objectives (NOT a grading rubric), the app’s response to what the student writes can come as Socratic questions (NOT a grade). I’d like to use the method for revision, IF I could develop an app that would let me read the essays and the chats. Humanly, finding time to do/remember all that reading is a design challenge. But it might work really well in a think/pair/share mode.

Expand full comment
Benjamin Riley's avatar

Perhaps unsurprisingly, I don't love it. In many ways, educators in the K12 space have been curating their own curriculum in similar fashion using sites such as Teacher Pay Teachers. That site and other like it are a wasteland of terrible lessons and task ideas that nonetheless get can great traction for all the wrong reasons (easy to implement, students may enjoy them, but no learning takes place). It's not clear to me that AI-produced materials are substantially better; my trial usage suggests they are often worse.

I think it's important to be careful not to "optimize" around what the most thoughtful teachers will do. The real test is how it cashes out with the practical day-to-day realities. And I've seen versions of this movie before.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?